St. Patty’s Day Bagels and Dinner in Bay Ridge – March 2025
Where can I get green bagels in Bay Ridge?
1) Bagel Villa at 7221 5th Avenue had these green and white bagels last year:
2) Bagel Boy 8002 – 3rd Avenue has green bagels every year, but they also started carrying the popular rainbow bagels
3) Sunset Bagels at 86th Street at 8624 – 5th Avenue had these green bagels:
4) H&L Bagels at 8818 3rd Avenue has green bagels on Friday, March 14, 2025.
Corned Beef and Cabbage in Bay Ridge
1) Mike’s Deli– 4th Avenue between 95th and 96th. They deliver 718-238-5200. $28.00 for a plate of corned beef and cabbage. They also have a corned beef sandwich for $18.00
This is what their plate looked like last year:
2) The Wicked Monk 9510 3rd Avenue has good corned beef and cabbage $25 on Saturday, Sunday and Monday. (See video) 347-497-5152.
3) The Bean Post 7525 – 5th Avenue Corned beef dinner (2025 price – $19.50. ) From Friday, March 14th to Monday, March 17th, Corned beef sandwich $15 – $17.50 (see below). I had their shepherd’s pie and it is very good. 718-238-6666.
4) Pippins Pub – 9023 3rd Avenue – We had this corned beef and cabbage and it was so good! Last year, Joe from Peppino’s visited Pippins. (See video) This year Pippins will have corned beef and cabbage dinner $24.95 Corned beef sandwich is $18.95. The Gaelic steak is $27.95 and Shepherd’s pie $20.95 on Saturday, Sunday and Monday.
5) The Greenhouse Cafe at 7717 – 3rd Avenue will have St. Patrick’s Day Dinner on Monday 3/17 and and live music at 6:00 pm. Call for a reservation: 718-833-8200. Pre-fix menu. They will also have corned beef on Sunday, 3/23 after the Bay Ridge St. Patrick’s Day Parade.
6) Skinflints at 7902 – 5th Avenue – best decorated place in Bay Ridge. They have corned beef dinner for $26.07 (includes tax). They are serving it on Sunday starting at 3:00 pm and Monday.
7) Salty Dog at 7509 – 3rd Avenue 718-238-0030. (They said they don’t have corned beef this year – 2025)
8) Schnitzel Haus at 7319 5th Avenue. 718-836-5600. $20 for this years Corned beef and cabbage plate – which is being served Friday, March 14th to Monday, March 17th. I have seen many people write on social media that this corned beef is very good.
2025 Schnitzel Haus:
2024 Schnitzel Haus:
9) Mike’s Royal Diner at 7609 – 5th Avenue has corned beef dinner for $28.99 (includes a soup or salad) 718-745-3444
10) Brooklyn Brew Cafe at 310 – 79th Street has served corned beef and potato soup for years. It’s $15.00. It looks amazing! We haven’t tried it yet, but their other soups are delicious.
11) Anthony’s Butcher And Deli at 7324 3rd Avenue – plates of corned beef and cabbage are $25 and sandwiches on rye bread for $18 will be available after 12:00 pm on Saturday, Sunday and Monday. (See video)
12) Annabelle’s Italian Restaurant at 717- 86th Street had corned beef: 718-836-9444 (2025 – they will not be having corned beef dinner)
13) Fort Hamilton Diner at 9502 4th Avenue will have corned beef, cabbage, potato and a soup available on Monday. A few years ago, I was sick on St. Patrick’s Day and Lee got me corned beef dinner from the diner. It was actually very good and it came with a slice of Irish soda bread. 718-238-5151
14) Tanoreen Middle Eastern Restaurant, which is well known for it’s amazing brussel sprouts, has corned beef with a lot of spices every year and it looks great. We haven’t tried it yet. Tanoreen is at 7523- 3rd Avenue. See their menu
1) Where can I get Irish soda bread in Bay Ridge?
1) Brooklyn Market has fresh soda bread in their bakery (since Leske’s is gone)
2) Bread Plus Bakery at 2841 Harway Avenue (It’s good)
3) Regina Bakery at 256 Prospect Park West has very good Irish soda bread. (This is the closest to my grandmother’s Irish soda bread).
4) Mikes Deli on 4th Avenue between 95th and 96th Street makes Irish Soda Bread.
5) Bitten Brooklyn has a large loaf or six mini loaves for $20. Homemade with grass-fed Irish butter, buttermilk, plump raisins & anise seeds. bittenbrooklyn@gmail.com
Outside of Bay Ridge in Sunset Park:
1) Irish Haven at 5721 – 4th Avenue is having specials on Sunday and Monday!
a) Sunday, March 16th at 6:00 pm – Contest to drink down to the G (on the Guiness pint) and win $50 tab.
b) Monday, March 17th – Guinness pints from 8:00 a.m. to noon $5.00. Corned beef sandwiches on Monday 3/17 from 12:00 – 6:00 pm.
2) Feeney’s Pub at 6201 – 5th Avenue
Hugs,
marlene
Topics: Bay Ridge | No Comments »